
The mashed potatoes look right in the bowl, but the first forkful is heavy and a little flat. You stir in another pat of butter and a splash of cream, and now they're richer, yet somehow still dull, the kind of side that gets a polite spoonful and nothing more.
This is not your fault. More butter and cream add richness, not brightness. Ina Garten's answer comes after the milk and butter: buttermilk, stirred in at the end until the potatoes turn creamy.
Why a tangy finish wakes up a heavy mash
In Ina Garten's buttermilk mashed potatoes, from her cookbook Barefoot Contessa at Home, the potatoes get warm milk and a stick of butter first. Then she adds ¾ to 1 cup of shaken buttermilk, just enough to make them creamy. Its tang is what sets this mash apart from the usual milk-and-butter version, cutting through the richness instead of adding to it.
Her method also protects the texture. She uses Yukon Golds, simmers them gently and passes them through a food mill instead of beating them. Overmixing in a blender or food processor releases large amounts of starch and turns potatoes gluey, one of the mashed potato mistakes that are hardest to fix.
Ina's buttermilk mash, step by step
The recipe serves 5 to 6.
- Salt the water. Bring 4 quarts of water and 2 tablespoons of kosher salt to a boil in a large pot.
- Cut evenly. Peel 3 pounds of Yukon Gold potatoes and cut them into 1½-inch cubes.
- Simmer gently. Add the potatoes, return to a boil, then lower the heat and simmer uncovered for 10 to 15 minutes, until a fork slides in easily. Drain right away.
- Warm the dairy. While the potatoes cook, heat ½ cup of whole milk and 1 stick of unsalted butter in a small saucepan without letting it boil.
- Mash and finish. Pass the potatoes through a food mill into a heatproof bowl, stir in the warm milk and butter, then add ¾ to 1 cup of buttermilk until creamy. Season with 2 teaspoons of kosher salt and ½ teaspoon of black pepper, adjusting to taste.
Plan B if you don't own a food mill: use a hand masher and stop as soon as the potatoes are smooth. Avoid the blender or food processor.
To hold the potatoes before dinner, Garten sets the bowl over a pan of simmering water for up to 30 minutes and stirs in a little extra hot milk to keep them creamy.
How rich this side really is
Buttermilk adds tang, but this is still a buttery dish. One stick of butter spread over 5 to 6 servings works out to about 1⅓ to 1½ tablespoons of butter per serving, by Lively Table's math. To lighten it, start with half the butter and let a little more buttermilk carry the creaminess, tasting as you go.
Watch the salt, too. The potatoes cook in salted water before 2 more teaspoons go into the bowl, so taste before adding the full amount, especially if you're limiting sodium.
The recipe relies on milk, butter and buttermilk, so it isn't suitable for anyone with a milk allergy. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours, and reheat them to 165°F, the temperature FoodSafety.gov lists for all leftovers, with a splash of milk to bring back the texture.
Warm the milk and butter, mash gently, and finish with buttermilk. That's the trick.



Leave a Reply