• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Recipes
  • Nutrition
  • Natural Living
  • Body Love
  • Sustainability
  • Lively Living
    • Baby Led Weaning
    • Pregnancy
    • Lively Littles Recipes
    • Baby Lifestyle
  • About
    • Contact

Lively Table logo

menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • Appetizers
  • Breakfast
  • Lunch
  • Main Dishes
  • Desserts
  • Sides
  • Vegetarian
  • Gluten Free
  • Pork
  • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
  • ×
    Home » Recipes » Desserts

    Forget store-bought pudding: this creamy homemade version starts with ordinary cookies

    BY LivelyTable Team · November 18, 2026

    Add LivelyTable to Google Preferred Sources
    Butter cookie pudding
    © Olga Mazyarkina

    You stir milk, sugar and cornstarch on the stove, pour it into little cups and slide them into the fridge. The next morning, the pudding is still loose and soupy, with a faint chalky taste. The kids go back to the plastic cups from the store.

    This is not your fault. Cornstarch only thickens when it gets hot enough, and many home cooks pull the pan off the heat too early. One popular homemade recipe fixes the flavor side of the problem too: it blends plain butter cookies right into the milk.

    Why the pan needs to reach a boil

    Cornstarch granules swell and set the pudding as they heat. The Iowa State University food preparation lab manual directs cooks to stir puddings gently over medium heat until the mixture boils, then keep cooking 2 to 3 minutes, stirring slowly but constantly. The goal is a tender gel with no lumps.

    The cookies change the rest of the recipe. Butter cookies bring wheat flour, butter and sugar to the pot. Blended into the milk, they carry their buttery flavor and some sweetness with them, which is why the recipe calls for only a modest amount of added sugar.

    Cookie pudding, step by step

    The quantities below are converted from the metric recipe and rounded.

    1. Blend the cookies. Blend about 6 ounces of plain butter cookies, such as petit beurre-style biscuits, with about 3 cups plus 3 tablespoons of milk until smooth.
    2. Mix the dry ingredients. In a saucepan, whisk together about 4½ tablespoons of sugar, about 4½ tablespoons of cornstarch and a pinch of salt.
    3. Combine. Gradually whisk the cookie milk into the saucepan until no dry lumps remain.
    4. Cook to a boil. Stir over medium heat until the mixture boils, then keep stirring for 2 to 3 minutes, until it thickly coats the back of a spoon.
    5. Flavor and chill. Take the pan off the heat, stir in a splash of vanilla and pour into cups. Press plastic wrap onto the surface to stop a skin from forming, then refrigerate at least 2 hours.

    Plan B if you want something less sweet for breakfast: Lively Table's banana coconut breakfast pudding gets most of its sweetness from ripe bananas.

    Keeping cookie pudding fresh and safe

    Homemade pudding doesn't keep like the sealed cups on the store shelf. Colorado State University Extension lists puddings and custards at 1 to 2 days in the refrigerator, and doesn't recommend freezing them. Keep the fridge between 35°F and 40°F, and don't leave the cups out at room temperature for more than 2 hours.

    Check the cookie label for allergens. Butter cookies are made with wheat flour and butter, and some brands add eggs or soy, so read the full ingredient list. For a gluten-free version, you'd need gluten-free cookies and a check that every ingredient is certified gluten-free.

    This is still dessert. Between the cookies and the added sugar, it's a sweet treat, so serve it in small cups. If you're managing diabetes, a registered dietitian can help you fit it into your plan.

    Blend the cookies into the milk, cook it to a boil, and give it 2 hours to set. That's the trick.

    « There's a reason aluminum foil has two different sides, and it's not about cooking

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Primary Sidebar

    Trending

    • Skinny margaritas with lime wedges.
      The BEST Skinny Margaritas
    • pinto beans a grey bowl with a black spoon beside it.
      The Best Easy Pinto Beans Recipe
    • piece of lobster ravioli cut in half on a black fork sitting on a plate of ravioli.
      Lobster Ravioli with Brown Butter Sauce
    • closeup of the cut side of a BBQ rib on a cutting board.
      BBQ Ribs on the Charcoal Grill
    • cooked black rice in a small grey bowl.
      How To Cook Black Rice
    • two layer cake with a layer of frosting in the middle and a dollop of frosting on top.
      How To Make Basic Cake Frosting
    • wooden spoon of easy spaghetti sauce over a white pot of sauce.
      The Simple Spaghetti Sauce I Make Instead of Buying Jars
    • closeup of simple roasted sweet potato cubes in a white bowl.
      Simple Roasted Sweet Potatoes
    As Featured in Sidebar Image

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    Latest Recipes

    • Aluminum foil roll
      There's a reason aluminum foil has two different sides, and it's not about cooking
    • Cheesy potato bake.
      A top French chef reveals the secret to a creamier potato and cheese bake, and it starts with the cheese
    • Milk jug stored in the fridge door
      Milk stays fresh longer in one spot of your fridge, and it’s not where most people keep it
    • Vintage McDonald's sign and logo
      McDonald's gave away these mugs in 1976, and some are now selling for up to $99

    Recipes

    • Breakfast
    • Gluten-Free
    • Vegetarian
    • Desserts
    • Grilling
    • Chicken & Turkey
    • Drinks and Cocktails
    • Sides
    • Main Dishes
    • Snacks

    About

    • Contact
    • About

    Copyright © 2026 Lively Table
    Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions